How The Alt-Right Blogosphere Is Destroying Society

At first I was amused.

Then, over time, my amusement gave way to concern.

Now, the political scientist in me is downright worried.

That describes the evolution of my thinking towards the the alt-right blogosphere.

For those unfamiliar, the “alt-right” is a label used to define the loose confederation of nationalists that view conventional conservatism as weak and generally incapable of countering the global shift towards progressive multiculturalism.

One of the alt-right’s most recognizable faces is that of Steve Bannon, the man President-elect Donald Trump named chief strategist back in November. Bannon is executive chairman of Breitbart News, a site that, as FT noted last month, has run stories with titles like “The Confederate flag proclaims a glorious heritage” and “Bill Kristol: Republican spoiler, renegade Jew”. Last year, Bloomberg described it as “the crusading right-wing populist website that’s a lineal descendant of the Drudge Report and a haven for people who think Fox News is too polite and restrained.”

bannon

(Bannon)

Although Breitbart’s CEO Larry Solov dismisses allegations of racism as “a smear tactic that has been concocted by a combination of leftwing activists, Hillary Clinton and the mainstream media,” it’s well nigh impossible to ignore the thinly-veiled message embedded in the site’s articles. Spend 10 minutes headline surfing on Breitbart and you’ll come away feeling as though you need a shower.

Apparently, the site has strayed from the editorial vision of its late founder Andrew Breitbart, who had a close relationship with Matt Drudge (of Drudge Report fame). Breitbart has, according some former employees, turned into the online echo chamber for Donald Trump who, via his Twitter account, provides a similar service to Breitbart.

With Bannon’s new role in the Trump administration, Breitbart “is positioned to become a paper of record,” Solov boasts.

google

 

Breitbart has emboldened a number of copycat sites that adopt a similar editorial bias and run the same type of inflammatory headlines. Breitbart and its progeny have a formulaic approach to producing content. They take a kernel of truth and inject it with so much bias and spin that it effectively becomes “fake news.”

For instance, say we find out that from 2006 to 2011, terrorist attacks killed 126 people in Europe but from 2012 to 2016, that figure rose to 281 (those are real figures). Now the first thing to note here is that that’s a sad statistic and no one would suggest that we attempt to sugarcoat it. On the other hand, we don’t want to be alarmists about it either and especially not if our only reason for being alarmists is to generate more pageviews, promote xenophobia and bigotry, or both. So how might an alt-right site or blog frame the statistic cited above? Well, they’re likely to come up with a headline like this: “Europeans Killed By Radical Muslims Soar 126% As Merkel’s Missteps Lead To Massacre.” The story under that headline would invariably be just as outlandish and overwrought as the title.

That’s how the alt-right blogosphere works. That’s how it prospers. And that’s how it inspires.

At the outset I said that I initially found all of this to be amusing. Why? Because there’s something terribly ironic about capitalizing on the publication of sensationalist articles while simultaneously bemoaning the dishonesty of the “mainstream liberal media” (a favorite target of the alt-right). Everything you read on one of these websites should have a giant, red “caveat emptor” stamp in the header and in case that’s not clear enough for some readers, perhaps there should be a “consider the source” warning in the margins. In short, the idea that these websites should criticize the mainstream media for being biased is the very definition of hypocrisy.

Breitbart and sites like it also inspire the burgeoning “fake news” industry, which caters to those who identify with the idea that mainstream conservatism is feeble and in need of a dramatic overhaul. “Fake news” created (literally) out of thin air has become so influential that some observers credit its authors with helping Donald Trump win the White House. Consider the following from an FT story that ran last month:

It was once known as “Tito’s Veles” in honour of the former Yugoslav leader who praised the gaily coloured porcelain tea sets its factories produced. But the small Macedonian riverside town of 44,000 is now better known for its wildly successful pro-Trump fake news websites.

More than a hundred US politics sites are run from Veles, where a handful of entrepreneurial Macedonian teenagers — apparently unconnected to American rightwing elements or alleged Russian operatives — produce hoax articles attracting millions of clicks and shares. One such article posted on December 6 said that Syrian terrorists had attacked New York. No such attack took place.

The emergence of a fake news industry in this unlikely spot in the Balkan hinterland may even have tipped the electoral balance in Donald Trump’s favour.

While that’s probably a bit strong, there’s no denying the fact that hundreds of thousands of netizens (some of whom apparently vote) are duped by stories that aren’t just biased or otherwise skewed, but are in fact completely made up. Here are some excerpts from an interview NPR conducted with a purveyor of make-believe narratives (emphasis mine):

On a warm, sunny afternoon I set out with a producer for a suburb of Los Angeles. Jestin Coler lived in a middle-class neighborhood of pastel-colored one-story beach bungalows. His home had an unwatered lawn — probably the result of California’s ongoing drought. There was a black minivan in the driveway and a large prominent American flag.

The whole idea from the start was to build a site that could kind of infiltrate the echo chambers of the alt-right, publish blatantly or fictional stories and then be able to publicly denounce those stories and point out the fact that they were fiction,” Coler says.

During the run-up to the presidential election, fake news really took off. “It was just anybody with a blog can get on there and find a big, huge Facebook group of kind of rabid Trump supporters just waiting to eat up this red meat that they’re about to get served,” Coler says. “It caused an explosion in the number of sites. I mean, my gosh, the number of just fake accounts on Facebook exploded during the Trump election.

Coler says his writers have tried to write fake news for liberals — but they just never take the bait.

“Liberals never take the bait” – imagine that.

But do you know who does take the bait? The growing ranks of disaffected voters that have found who they believe to be their saviors in populist/nationalist politicians like Trump, like Nigel Farage, like Marine le Pen, like Geert Wilders, and like Frauke Petry. All of their stars have risen.

Here are some recent poll numbers that presage a strong showing for Europe’s populist candidates in this year’s elections:

populist

(Charts: Citi)

The groundswell of support for populism/nationalism comes at the expense of globalization and multiculturalism, two pillars of societal advancement.

But don’t think for a second that the growing ranks of alt-right bloggers and fake news distributors care.

Unconcerned with the real-world ramifications of their disingenuous online banter, they revel in the fact that they can exploit uneducated readers, conspiracy theorists, and those who generally lack critical thinking skills for their own personal gain (it is not unusual for the owners of these web properties to make between $10,000 and $100,000 per month).

One can only hope that eventually, the most influential of the bunch will see the danger in what they’re helping to create and disavow it. But I’m not optimistic.

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “How The Alt-Right Blogosphere Is Destroying Society

  1. Like religion, fake news is bread and butter for uneducated masses. I would have used ‘opium”, but that may have not been understood by those very same people.

    Like

    • I’ve work withed five different universities and their faculties regarding biotech related projects. I’ve been on several of their technical advisory boards and one NASA program technical advisory board, and trust me when I say that the general lack of critical thinking skills in the US are not just limited to the uneducated.

      Like

  2. The snow flakes keep falling, now is the winter of their discontent. Winter has come, they can not bare the warmth nor the glow of any distant fire save their own. Seek solace in the ocean of ideas, we all come from there, do not let it freeze.

    Like

  3. There has to be a boogie man someone or some thing to blame as it can’t be my fault for my shitty life. The alt-right is the direct result of BS that is accepted as truth and made-up BS that is not held accountable by anyone anymore. Fake news,fake politicians,fake outrage, fake economy, pretty soon we will have fake money. Maybe it already is…

    Like

  4. The Honey Badger is a man to be feared. He is relentless when he attacks which is the reason he was selected by Trump. He has no rules other than winning and will do so no matter the cost or the effort expended,

    Like

  5. Granting the right is guilty as charged to one degree or another, the left is just as or more deficient in not picking up on real news. That is, aside from sarcastic reference, there has been little reporting of the actual newsworthiness of “for instance” the Pedestal emails by the mainstream left leaning media. All the “news” is about how they got here and nothing about the cynical sometimes illegal content exposed by the release of them. This was not a campaign that deserved to win either. A pox on both houses.

    Like

  6. Hey Heisenberg, I followed you here from Seeking Alpha to see some of your political commentary. Just browsing some of your headlines let me know where you are in the spectrum, but I read content from all points of view.

    I disagree with your assertion that the alt-right blogosphere is destroying society, for several reasons:

    Alt-right websites have a limited readership and probably didn’t reach the millions of critical swing voters who switched from Obama voters to Trump voters. Anyone who voted for Obama is not going to be reading Breitbart articles. People who voted for Trump didn’t need the alt-right sites to convince them.

    The tiny number of alt-right websites are greatly overbalanced by extreme left websites like HufPo, MSNBC, Slate, Mother Jones and dozens more. If you add in the broadcast news networks and the newspapers, the left bias of the media is very, very solid.

    Fake news based on grains of truth has been the stock in trade of the mainstream media for at least a couple of decades, if not longer. It is nothing new except for the recent appearance of people doing it for profit.

    But all this misses the big picture. In my mind, the most serious problem we face right now in relation to the news media is the complete lack of accurate news.

    The mainstream (left-leaning) media bitterly hates Trump with every fiber of their intestinal tracts. You can’t blame them, since he made fools of them throughout the whole election process. All their energy is now going into delegitimizing Trump rather than finding real news and reporting it. We can’t trust anything they say for the foreseeable future. Nor can we trust the alt-right web sites or the one right-leaning cable news network.

    The media has become so hyperpartisanized that we are really up the proverbial creek when it comes to knowing what is going on in our government. This is a real problem when we are all trying to understand a very unusual new President and figure out how to plan ahead for whatever changes he brings.

    I wish you would write about the collapse of the news media as a useful information source.

    Like

  7. I’m not entirely sure of the actual impact of the fake news. Millions of people are disfranchised in USA and EU and that not because of some balkan website. The heroin epidemic in idyllic little Vermont village has not been created by breitbart….

    ”The groundswell of support for populism/nationalism comes at the expense of globalization and multiculturalism, two pillars of societal advancement”

    Those two pillar might have forgotten a lot of worker in the last four decade and if fake news become real news the poor will still be poor. The ghetto will still be the ghetto.

    The rise of populism as deep root….what website people use for their daily ”recreative indignation” (breitbart, Buzzfeed, Fox, MSNBC etc.) is somewhat irrelevant.

    Like

  8. Ditto. My love of country has taken a big hit over the last year, not only from political outcomes but also just from cultural observations and experiences and the evolution of capitalism to its money sucking to the top self.

    I’m more radical now — but don’t know how to best express that other than “writing letters” — than I was as a 17 year old pot smoking (pre med cannabis), war protesting “freak” in 1969.

    Buying the dips in scales now — the thing that has worked the best for me over the years — feels like I am just feeding the beast. 😦

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s