Japan Goes To War With Kuroda’s BoJ Over Plunging Yen

The Bank of Japan is now effectively at war with the Japanese finance ministry, an absurd outcome months in the making. Masato Kanda, Japan's top currency official, confirmed the first intervention since 1998 on Thursday, the same day Haruhiko Kuroda stuck assiduously to the script while reiterating the central bank's intention to remain steadfast in monetary accommodation for the foreseeable future. "We won't raise rates for some time," Kuroda said, adding that the bank debated the proper cou

Get the best daily market and macroeconomic commentary anywhere for less than $7 per month.

Subscribe today

Already have an account? log in

Speak your mind

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

5 thoughts on “Japan Goes To War With Kuroda’s BoJ Over Plunging Yen

  1. Kuroda fought for years to arrest stagnant or even falling prices in Japan. Prior leaders at the BOJ failed at this. While we may disparage his policy, it is well to understand what has gone down in Japan since the property bust / banking problem dating back to the late 80s. He may want to stay the course to finally get Japan out of the lowflation regime there. Japan has other problems too- and Kuroda probably would rather have his successors deal with higher inflation down the road, than endure another 30 years of stagnation. I doubt his policy has to do with his personal legacy of maintaining a yield peg.

    1. It’s not a peg. It’s a cap. And that’s part and parcel of the whole discussion. That’s the crux of the issue. Defending that cap is a key pillar of the easing regime, and that defense entails printing endless (literally) amounts of money. You do realize he can be compelled to do this every, single weekday, right? The market can force him to print yen simply by challenging that cap. The more he prints, the more pressure on the currency, and that’s on top of the fact that the cap itself serves to pressure the currency because it means that on any day when 10-year JGB yields are bumping up against 0.25% and US yields are rising, rate diffs are moving against the yen. He’s risking a crisis. In my opinion, he should be removed from his post now, before this gets worse. This wasn’t a problem until this year. He refuses to recognize that the situation has changed. It isn’t tenable. At the least, he has to widen the YCC band. Has to. Has to. Has to. But here’s the rub: As soon as he does, the market will challenge the new upper limit. So he’ll then have to print more to defend that cap. There’s no way out of this unless US yields (and particularly US reals) retreat and the dollar weakens. This isn’t the old “central banks are trapped” cliché that everyone with a soapbox has rolled out over the past dozen years. He’s literally trapped. The failure to appreciate this sort of thing is the stuff crises are made of.

      1. That’s very clear but what’s your take on what happens the moment they let go of the yield cap?

        I’d have thought widening it might be a decent half way house but certainly past experiences in the Euro (ecu as it was called back then) system do not impart lots of confidence…

        1. Oh, it’d be even worse! But if that’s the argument for keeping it, then they need to make that crystal clear. So, they need to say something like this: “Look, this was arguably sustainable until this year, but the combination of rising rates across DMs, the plunging currency and the impact of the latter on the trade balance and other fundamental pillars of economic and financial stability, have conspired to make it untenable. However, having acknowledged that, we’ve come to conclusion after a serious internal debate, that scrapping our policy settings in the current environment is even more dangerous than keeping them, and here’s why. [XYZ.] Therefore, these settings will remain in place until conditions are more favorable for adjustments. We want to make it clear that in the interim, attempts to force us away from these settings will be terminated with extreme prejudice. That said, we reiterate that we understand the market’s concerns and that we do intend to address them as soon as it’s feasible. Thank you, no questions today.”

          The problem with that, though, if you’re the BoJ, is what do you say about this ridiculous juxtaposition where you have the finance ministry selling dollars while you (the BoJ) are printing yen? The upward pressure on the yield cap is what’s causing this. And, as you suggest in your comment, letting all of that pressure out at once could be very perilous. The yen, for example, could rally so hard, so fast, that it’d be destabilizing. And there’s no liquidity in the JGB market. None. There were no trades in benchmark 10-year JGBs for two straight days this week.

          So, I don’t know. That’s really all I’m trying to say with these BoJ articles. I don’t know what the solution is, but I do know that unless US yields and the dollar fall on their own, this’ll remain a pressure cooker.

          1. Understood. As you said, kinda like the Fed, they waited too long to react to the US inflation and its foreseeable impact on US rates. But unlike the Fed, they’re really cornered.

NEWSROOM crewneck & prints