‘Fire Fauci!’ Failing The Rationality Test In The Kingdom Of Unreason

Over the weekend, Donald Trump’s favorite pandemic adviser, Scott Atlas, appeared on Russian state television to deride lockdowns and implicitly criticize Anthony Fauci.

America’s public health experts are “killing people with their fear-inducing shutdown policies,” Atlas told RT which, again, is Russian state television. It was a surreal spectacle: A US government official charged with protecting the public from a deadly epidemic appearing on a Kremlin-backed news channel to criticize America’s scientific community, just three days before an election that national security officials say Russia has been tampering with for months.

Atlas later apologized. “I was unaware they are a registered foreign agent,” he shrugged, in a Sunday tweet. “I regret doing the interview and apologize for allowing myself to be taken advantage of.”

Read more: An Eleventh Hour Election Warning For Traders And Investors

For his part, Fauci said Atlas is “talking about things that I believe he doesn’t have any real insight or knowledge or experience in.”

“I have real problems with that guy,” Fauci added.

The US nearly topped 100,000 virus cases in a single day late last week. And yet, during a marathon rally tour, Trump continued to insist the country is “rounding the turn.” That’s a lie. It’s not reality. And this isn’t a matter of partisanship or casting aspersions. Rather, Trump simply isn’t telling the truth. The seven-day average for new infections is now at nearly 80,000.

Although deaths remain steady, that in itself is a problem. You don’t want fatalities to be “steady.” The US is losing around 800 people per day to the virus.

In a testament to the pernicious effect rhetoric from officials like Atlas has, loud chants of “Fire Fauci” broke out at a Trump rally Sunday after the president ludicrously claimed the media will stop talking about COVID-19 after the election if Joe Biden wins.


“Don’t tell anybody, but let me wait until a little bit after the election. I appreciate the advice,” Trump told the crowd. “No, he’s been wrong on a lot. He’s a nice man, though. He’s been wrong on a lot.”

As ever, irony is dead in the Trump era. And so is satire. For the duration of the pandemic, Trump has insisted (loudly) that COVID-19 will just “disappear.” It never did. In fact, it eventually infected him.

On Sunday, The White House suggested Fauci is a deep state operative. Fauci’s remarks to The Washington Post criticizing the administration’s virus response are “exactly what the American people have come to expect from The Swamp,” spokesman Judd Deere said, in a statement.

Again, that’s surreal — an official statement from The White House using the terminology of a demagogue.

With that in mind, I’ll leave you with two short passages from a new NotesFromDisgraceland commentary (below).

1.XI 2020

Declownification of sovereignty

When the number of those who have failed the rationality test is so large that they begin to present a significant political body whose voice can be heard in the ballot box, rationality will already exhaust itself. At that point, the excluded will seek to abandon reason and, with the help of nostalgia and identity politics, elect a new Prince. And this Prince will be unlike any other before him. He will govern with unwisdom and will have the courage to wear his unreason unabashedly as an ultimate virtue. He will create a new order of things, define new reality, and construct the world of unreason with rules that only he & his constituents understand.

In this kingdom of unreason, power will derive from a way of using language rather than from a system of ideas. But this, like any other detachment from reality, cannot be anything but short-lived. The Prince will sit in his big car, get on a highway and drive against the traffic. His car will have only one pedal: Gas. Like his constituents, he believes that everyone else is driving in the wrong direction. Many drivers will move to the shoulder to avoid the collision, but, as he continues to accelerate, there’ll be a slow-moving trailer truck that won’t be able to maneuver fast enough.

Follow NotesFromDisgraceland on Twitter here


6 comments on “‘Fire Fauci!’ Failing The Rationality Test In The Kingdom Of Unreason

  1. northwest says:

    On a positive note…
    “But this, like any other detachment from reality, cannot be anything but short-lived.”

  2. gdhalpha says:

    I would like to think that if Trump fired Fauci, one of the major legit media outlets would pick him up and give him a platform to provide truthful information. And maybe Fauci would feel more free to call it as he sees it rather than hiding from Trump

  3. Anonymous says:

    I suspect that he’s not ‘hiding’. The truth is that he’s probably restricted from access to media outlets and in what information he could pass on to the media if allowed an interview. What you’re suggesting is why Trump isn’t going to fire him. Unless Trump is re-elected and no longer wants to pretend that he actually cares what happens to the American people.

  4. Fauci’s mistake was trying to keep Trump happy enough that he wouldn’t get fired and
    would be able to influence the Gov’ts response. All he did was give Trump credibility, by standing next to him while he lied to Americans.

  5. Nobody says:

    Trump can’t fire Fauci. He’s not a political appointee but rather a Federal Civil Service employee. The Director of NIH (his “supervisor”) could with cause, and that would be hard to prove and a circus. Trump did what he could, which is to appoint a radiologist with minimal experience in infectious disease or epidemiology to be his Covid advisor. Likely the only M.D. he could find who met the ultimate test: loyalty to Trump.

Speak your mind

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.