Vanke, Last Of The Giants, Nears Default

China Vanke’s special. Or at least it was.

In a property sector where every major developer experienced some manner of credit event over the course of a downturn that’s entering its fifth year, Vanke’s the last of the giants.

It’s not about what Vanke did right or even about what it didn’t do wrong. Rather, Vanke owes its durability to the assumption that it’s an arm’s length organ of the Chinese state via its largest shareholder, Shenzhen Metro Group, an SOE with a stake that exceeds 27%.

Vanke has in excess of $50 billion in debt, around 15% of which is held by offshore creditors. On its own, it’s insolvent. Or so determined CICC, which the Party sent in to evaluate the situation.

Shenzhen Metro has repeatedly stepped in to save the day, and when things started to look really dicey a few months back, there were scattered reports that the rail provider could fold Vanke into its own balance sheet. You know, to stave off a destabilizing worst-case.

But that rumor was quashed when Xin Jie, Shenzhen Metro’s long-serving chairman, disappeared on or around the beginning of October, as high-profile executives of embattled enterprises are wont to do in China.

Xin was installed to manage Vanke’s business in January, when the developer flagged a massive loss for the previous year. Markets saw in Xin’s dual role confirmation that the state would continue to back Vanke through loans and other financial guarantees provided by Shenzhen Metro. His abrupt resignation from Vanke’s leadership for “personal reasons,” announced in an October 12 filing, was the beginning of the end.

Less than a month later, Shenzhen Metro asked Vanke to post collateral for loans it’d already received — loans the developer used to repay principal and interest on bonds. Although Vanke was poised to get another $3 billion in liquidity, it indicated an upper limit on future lending from its state-owned benefactor.

Suddenly, markets were compelled to grapple with the prospect of finite state support at a time when sales remain in a hopeless tailspin and Western ratings agencies have telegraphed an almost certain default. The bonds are beset.

“We have revised down our contracted sales forecast for China Vanke to a decline of 47% in 2025,” S&P said last month, projecting negative cash flow from operations and downgrading the company to CCC with a negative outlook. “Vanke could default on its debt obligations if it does not receive timely and sufficient loans from Shenzhen Metro.”

That brings us to Monday, when Vanke was forced to sweeten the terms on an extension request for what’s now a past due CNY2 billion note. Late last week, lenders rejected a trio of proposals that would’ve given Vanke another year to pay.

Vanke on Monday said it could find CNY60 million to pay interest on the bond by next week, and offered lenders unspecified credit enhancements in exchange for a 12-month reprieve on payment of principal.

Technically, Vanke has just five days to get this sorted out, but the developer’s hoping to secure an extension on the grace period to 30 days. If that’s not granted, or if it is and Vanke can’t persuade lenders to accept a restructuring by this time next month, the last of the giants could be felled by a default declaration.

The creditors with the most to lose — in terms of recovery rates, anyway — are offshore debtors owed nearly $5.5 billion. As Shuli Ren explained, their claim isn’t on Vanke, but rather on a Hong Kong subsidiary whose principal asset is partially pledged for a preexisting loan. Bottom line: Offshore creditors owed billions would have to vie for a piece of an asset worth a mere $950 million.

As Ren went on to point out, Vanke’s mega-bank lenders — which include all the big guns in China — “have significant dealings” with Vanke proper, which is to say the actual developer on the mainland as opposed to the Hong Kong subsidiary. Those banks, Ren wrote, “will find ways to force Vanke to put up collateral just like Shenzhen Metro did” last month.

So, the bad news is, Vanke’s probably going to default and offshore creditors are going to be left holding the bag. The good news is, if Xi Jinping feels comfortable letting it go, it’s probably not a systemic risk.

As for Xin Jie, he’s still missing.


 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

One thought on “Vanke, Last Of The Giants, Nears Default

  1. In spite of Xi’s efforts to stop the wealthy from transferring their wealth out of China, it is estimated that as much as $300B- $1T left China via illegal means (crypto and/or not repatriating cash flow from foreign subsidiaries, among other means of illegal transfers) in 2024. This is in addition to the $50,000/ annually per family member that is legal.
    Hard to think it would be wise to invest in an economy facing significant capital flight. UK and China have this in common.

Create a free account or log in

Gain access to read this article

Yes, I would like to receive new content and updates.

10th Anniversary Boutique

Coming Soon