Is Any Of It Real?

Is Any Of It Real?

Equities are having a good run. Perhaps you noticed.

Thank the now ubiquitous reflation narrative. Or, relatedly, thank vaccine optimism. Or thank central banks for ensuring that there really is “no alternative” and that it’s possible to justify virtually any multiple, no matter how ostensibly absurd, by reference to low bond yields.

The MSCI World was on track to start the new week with an eleventh consecutive gain. Not too shabby, right?

By now, most market participants have heard it all when it comes to justifications for the ongoing rally. Similarly, anyone mired in the cacophony (which is deafening at times) is well-versed in the other side of the debate, where that just means you can probably recite the myriad reasons why the euphoria doesn’t make much sense, why it’s not sustainable, and why “it’s never different this time.”

I imagine this is probably pretty daunting for new market entrants. Or at least for those inclined to believe there’s supposed to be something behind it all — something real beyond the lines on the screens. (Nihilistic Redditors need not necessarily apply.)

Indeed, this is all pretty daunting even for finance professors. I spoke to one Monday who had a laundry list of questions about Elon Musk and Tesla (prompted by an article published here). Eventually, I resorted to a tried-and-true method for communicating how the seemingly nonsensical can make sense: I referred back to several articles from autumn of 2019, when negative corporate bond yields in Europe were grabbing headlines.

In August of that year, the face value of negative-yielding euro corporate bonds was around €1 trillion. Conceptually, those companies could mint “assets.” Or something. It’s difficult to fathom. And that’s always my point when I use that example. If corporate curves can be negative, who’s to say what Tesla or Bumble “can” or “can’t” be worth?

But maybe it’s not so insane. As SocGen’s Andrew Lapthorne reminded market participants in a Monday note, “for all its complexity, the equity market is quite a simple beast; it tends to ebb and flow with the direction of profit and profits expectations.”

Expectations for corporate profits have been revised higher recently. Goldman, for example, hiked their already above-consensus forecast for S&P 500 EPS last week. Fourth quarter earnings for corporate America actually managed to grow YoY with 84% of market cap reporting. Consensus had been looking for an 11% decline headed into reporting season.

Read more: What Virus? Corporate Profits Surpassed Pre-Pandemic Levels In Q4

And yet, there’s still a sense in which it’s all either contrived, a game, or a little of both.

“Analysts’ EPS expectations tend to be coincident with share price changes, so it is unclear if actual economic activity is changing the EPS or whether it is due to the need to justify a higher/lower share price target,” Lapthorne went on to say, adding that “these changes are also remarkably seasonal, with upgrades seen during the reporting season and downgrades more common thereafter as companies position and then ‘surprise’ the consensus.”

Who’s gaming who? And if everyone is gaming each other, then is any of it real?

I don’t know. Nobody does. Amusingly, even when you take into consideration higher expected earnings, multiples still end up looking elevated. Lapthorne noted that analysts now see “a 30% rise in MSCI World EPS for this year.” And yet, he marveled that “the overall P/E on MSCI World is still over 20x based on these end-2021 numbers.”

That’s not terribly worrying if bond yields stay low. But some expect yields to rise, even as they simultaneously admit central banks retain the capacity to tamp them down virtually at will.

Again: Is any of it real? And if not, then why not Bitcoin? Why not Dogecoin? Why not tulips?


 

8 thoughts on “Is Any Of It Real?

  1. I’m not sure if anyone has noticed this yet, but Mother Nature has finally accomplished something that Tony Fauci, countless health wags, and a heard of politicians were unable to achieve in a year. From last Friday to this coming Friday, virtually the entire country is in complete lockdown. Political bias and carelessness all trumped by 10 degree temperatures and a foot of snow outside your door.

    Covid was already on the ropes (rather mysteriously, to me). Five to seven days of coast-to-coast winter storm quarantine will, I suspect, noticeably accelerate its demise. It will be interesting to see if this gets picked up in markets. Perhaps I’m just overprojecting my own experience.

  2. I hate having so much in cash – about 3 years expenses – but bonds just aren’t that attractive. What fixed income are you in? I’m in the basic aggregate fund, plus some tips, plus a little long term munis. But the safest bonds I have seem to be I Bonds and EE bonds. But there’s a limit on how much you can buy.

    1. I have a question–why not something like Altria which has a robust divvy payout as opposed to bonds? Or some type of corporate with a low P/E and a dividend? Are you worried it just gets swept up like all the overpriced stuff in a massive correction? Too correlated with whatever else you own?

    2. It is never a bad idea to have 3 years expenses in cash. If something ever goes seriously wrong in your life (and I hope all of my readers stay healthy, happy and prosperous), that allocation will seem like the best investment decision you ever made.

  3. If present value is the sum of discounted cash flows, the variables are: How much cash? When? What’s the discount rate? With low discount rates (I don’t know how to handle negative rates!) future cash flows are worth much more today. Ultimately, you have to ask yourself, ” Compared to what?” We have some VERY low bond rates out there to compare to/use as discount rates.

  4. What happens when central banks and the SEC experience regulatory capture? Is Bitcoin as crazy as it seems in that scenario? Heck even Doge could comparatively have utility at that point. Sometimes even a joke is better than the alternative. Not saying we’re there but are we headed there? Are we close?

Leave a Reply to calh0025 Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.