Womp, womp. Sad trombone.
Is it even worth covering anymore? China’s monthly activity data, I mean?
During some months, I honestly think the answer’s “no.” But it does count as a top-tier global macro release and China’s the world’s second-largest economy. So I’ll soldier on.
As a quick aside, there was time when this release was so important — or so important in my mind — that I’d pre-write as much of my coverage as possible each month, then sit at my terminal waiting for the headlines to cross so I could update my charts and rush out an article. That seems absurd now, a decade on, but then so do a lot of things.
The issue with this release is just that it shows the same thing month after painful month: Lackluster domestic demand as proxied by barely-there retail sales growth and contracting fixed investment. Both of those trends are stories, but I’m tired of telling them, mostly because I’ve run out of CCP-themed jokes and smart-sounding balance sheet recession one-liners.
Anyway, retail sales in China rose… well, barely at all last month, according to figures out Monday. The 0.4% YoY advance was a bad miss to consensus and counted as the worst result since August. (And that’s its own joke, isn’t it? This was the worst readout since the one before the last readout.)
There’s the chart. It’s hopeless. Domestic demand’s dead. And waiting on the Party to revive consumption is like waiting on “infrastructure week” in the US: Headlines like “China’s Economy Disappoints With New Stimulus Yet to Kick In” are a standing joke now.
That dearth of homegrown demand is one side of the overcapacity equation. Unless and until Chinese households stop deleveraging, the country will have a surfeit of cheap goods, which’ll be foisted onto global markets, resulting in trillion-dollar trade imbalances.
The cumulative, YTD decline in fixed-asset investment was 8.1% through October, according to Monday’s release. That’s horrible. Economists expected the decline to moderate from the January-September cumulative drop.
China’s on track for a second straight year of falling FAI, led lower by property investment, which dove a truly “impressive” 21.6% in the first 10 months of the year versus the same period a year ago.
There’s the chart for the property slump. It’s the worst ever. And it’s intractable.
Insult to injury: Industrial output grew a mere 4.8% in October, the slowest YoY rate since July and a miss to consensus.
All in all, this was a pretty rough release. The NBS offered a more upbeat assessment, even as the official statement retained a cautionary cadence. The Chinese economy, the Party said Monday, is “stable overall.”




Coverage of China is never boring. Xi is using the $1.2T trade imbalance to fund purchases of Russian oil, provide chips/drones to Iran and finance North Korea.
US accounts for $.3T of the $1.2T trade surplus. Europe is cozying up with China and buying lots of Chinese autos- implicitly financing China (and their “dependents”), agreeing to be tracked and potentially subjected to overrides in the software that operates the automobiles.
We are all just choosing to ignore this because we like relatively “cheap” stuff.
We are always at “war” with someone about something. Global peace or even global cooperation will never happen as long as that mindset is dominant. When you distrust someone, even innocuous actions seem suspicious.
A simple observation which is true and carries the trajectory which will lead to the end of civilization as we know it. There are now over 200 sovereign nations comprising some 8.5 billion individuals crowded on our planet. Each nation has its own history, leadership, societal agenda, resources, and other identifying characteristics. Because the way each of these nations was made, what it aspires to become and the nature of its people, the likelihood of cooperation amongst these nations has to be rated at near zero. I am willing to bet my HS-aged grandchild is unlikely to have grandchildren.