‘The Rich Will Keep Spending’

They were still spending last month. In nominal terms, anyway.

I don’t know who “they” were, though, because consumer spending in the US is allegedly confined to the upper-half of the so-called “K,” where stock portfolios took a hit in October. We’re halfway through November and equities are still bleeding. Hold that thought.

Control group sales in Tuesday’s release from the Commerce Department — the only top-tier US macro update on the schedule this week — doubled up consensus with 0.6% MoM advance.

As the figure shows, that’s a marked improvement from September’s slowdown and should bolster Q4 GDP tracking.

Let’s linger on this for a moment. Recall that control group sales rose the most since late 2024 in August from July. In September, the growth rate decelerated dramatically, or so we thought.

Tuesday’s release found Commerce revising the September print meaningfully higher — it now shows a respectable 0.5% advance versus the initially-reported 0.1% uptick — but it was the final revision for August that really stood out. That month now reflects the biggest increase since January of 2023. The top pane in the figure below gives you some context via callouts for the COVID “stimmy” spending months.

August’s finalized control group print counts as the 15th-largest ever in data going back nearly 35 years. So, it goes down as a 97%ile month.

With Tuesday’s provisional print for October and the revisions to September and August, the three-month average annualized pace of control group sales is now 8.4%, up from 5.8%. As the bottom pane in the figure shows, that’s the best pace since June of 2022, when inflation peaked in America.

Suffice to say it’s not just data center construction holding up the US economy, although when you factor in the extent to which the AI buildout’s bolstering equity prices, and thereby the wealth effect, I suppose you could argue it actually is.

The heatmap above shows you the category breakdown. Seven of 13 major aggregates showed a gain this month. One was unchanged.

On the headline, overall nominal spending rose 0.2% versus 0.1% seen. The ex-autos print showed a 0.6% advance versus 0.4% expected. Stripping out cars and gas, the MoM gain was 0.5%.

Coming full circle, it’s worth asking what happens to this apparently resilient spending impulse in the event stocks keep falling.

The chart above plots the Fed’s tally of the quarterly change in household equity portfolios with BofA’s estimates for Q3 and QTD for Q4.

Those portfolios have shed $3 trillion on paper over the last month, BofA reckoned late last week, using private client holdings as a reference.

But, as the bank’s Michael Hartnett was keen to point out, US household equity wealth’s still up $9 trillion YTD, which means the “rich will keep spending.”


 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

6 thoughts on “‘The Rich Will Keep Spending’”

  1. Take a moment to appreciate the depth of this coverage versus other outlets’ retail sales coverage today. Again: The data processing and charting capabilities here have taken a quantum leap.

      1. So spending categories that are benefiting from those born after 80’s/90’s, who aren’t getting married/having children.
        Both of my daughters furnished their rental homes almost entirely from Facebook Marketplace- saved a lot of money and their homes look great! One daughter was looking at cars on FB Marketplace, as well. Fortunately, she opted for the car from CarMax at a slightly higher price.

10th Anniversary Boutique

Coming Soon