Powell Reiterates Fed ‘Not Confident’ Rates Are High Enough

Headed into Jerome Powell’s speaking engagement on Thursday, some market observers (myself among them) suggested he’d do well to signal a bit of trepidation regarding the cross-asset rally witnessed in the aftermath of the November FOMC meeting.

Of course, no one expected Powell to explicitly reprimand traders or mention the S&P 500. Rather, some Fed watchers suggested he might simply reiterate the message from his remarks at an October event hosted by The Economic Club of New York. That message: Policy isn’t too tight, the economy is, by appearances anyway, just fine and there’s no reason to believe that any sort of dovish course correction will be necessary anytime soon.

You could quite plausibly argue that Powell’s message as delivered during last week’s press conference wasn’t materially different from his remarks two weeks prior, if it was any different at all. But that misses the point: Whatever Powell meant to convey last week, the market took the totality of his comments as tacit confirmation that rate hikes are over. The message was amplified by a run of soft data punctuated by a cooler-than-expected headline jobs print.

Stocks surged, bond yields tumbled (helped by smaller-than-expected increases to coupon issuance in the November refunding announcement) and financial conditions eased materially, effectively negating a meaningful portion of the FCI tightening Powell and his colleagues spent the better part of five weeks suggesting might stand in for the final rate hike. That’s the Fed’s FCI reflexivity trap.

Suffice to say the FCI tightening brought about by the term premium repricing and attendant long-end selloff since August threatens to be ephemeral, the opposite of the “persistent” impulse Powell insisted the Fed would need to see in order for market-based financial conditions to be relevant for monetary policy.

At Thursday’s IMF event, Powell delivered a boilerplate address that broke little new ground, where that means none. Inflation, he said, has “given us a few head fakes.” The Committee is aware of, and attentive to, the risks of being “misled” by the incoming data and also to the risks of over-tightening. The process of restoring price stability has “a long way to go,” Powell emphasized.

Although the Fed intends to proceed with caution, they won’t hesitate to hike again, according to Powell, who said that although “the broader supply recovery continues, it is not clear how much more will be achieved by additional supply-side improvements.” Looking ahead, it’s eminently possible that “a greater share of the progress in reducing inflation will have to come from tight monetary policy restraining the growth of aggregate demand.”

If there was a market-moving line in Powell’s prepared remarks, it was probably just his reiteration that the Fed’s not yet prepared to suggest publicly that policy settings are adequately tight to achieve price stability as central banks arbitrarily define it.

“The FOMC is committed to achieving a stance of monetary policy that is sufficiently restrictive to bring inflation down to 2% over time,” Powell said. “We are not confident that we have achieved such a stance.”


 

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 thoughts on “Powell Reiterates Fed ‘Not Confident’ Rates Are High Enough

  1. As you anticipated yesterday in “Rally Risks,” Powell “typically doesn’t lean against the price action until it’s ‘too late’.” The Fed and Powell have become an ongoing clown show.

  2. I have been puzzled by the persistent conviction, among many market strategists, watchers, and participants, including the rate futures market, that the Fed is going to start cutting in . . . well, in about three quarters from whatever the current quarter is. So currently 2Q-3Q of ‘24.

    This seems equivalent to conviction that inflation will be back to, or nearly at and rapidly heading to, 2% . . . in 2Q-3Q ‘24.

    If not, then it must be conviction that unemployment will be surging, banks failing, consumers breaking, and other hard landing indica . . . in 2Q-3Q ‘24.

    But I don’t see much conviction in either of those things.

    1. Consumer behavior is finally starting to change. Food companies are offering promotions & discounts again. And now even wealthier consumers around the world are stepping back from luxury goods. Perhaps they have, indeed, run down those “excess” savings enough to impact their spending?

Create a free account or log in

Gain access to read this article

Yes, I would like to receive new content and updates.

10th Anniversary Boutique

Coming Soon