Good News Is Definitely Bad News Now

For once, “scorching” isn’t hyperbole.

The US services sector is on fire, according to the last of this week’s top-tier US data.

At 69.1, ISM services printed a new record high in November (figure below). Consensus expected 65. The range of estimates was 62 to 67.5, so the actual headline was well ahead of the hottest guess from 60 economists.

The final read on IHS Markit’s gauge for November was 58, up from the 57 flash print. Although still very robust, Markit’s index telegraphed a slight deceleration in activity versus October.

The new record on ISM’s gauge was the fifth of 2021. Records were also set in October, July, May and March. The business activity gauge hit 74.6, while the new orders index printed 69.7.

“Demand continues to outpace supply that has been impacted by capacity constraints, shortages of labor and materials and logistical challenges,” ISM’s Anthony Nieves said Friday. “This has also caused demand-pull inflation that is affecting overall business conditions.”

So, the US economy is experiencing both cost-push and demand-pull inflation. And wage growth is running at a record clip.

At 82.3, the prices index on the ISM survey was the third-highest ever. Backlogs retreated a bit from October, but remained very elevated. Nieves said services businesses “continue to struggle replenishing inventories.” Accordingly, inventory sentiment hit a record low.

Virtually all of the anecdotes from ISM respondents echoed familiar concerns. Deliveries are late, everything is in short supply, including labor, and costs are increasing.

IHS Markit chief economist Chris Williamson told a similar story. Manufacturing constraints are spilling over into the services sector, he said, citing unprecedented backlogs as companies “often lacked the capacity to meet demand.”

Cost pressures were acute for services providers last month, he went on to say, flagging soaring input costs and job vacancies. “The rate of inflation [is] running just shy of May’s all-time peak,” he remarked.

If you think we’ve entered a “good news is bad news” regime, ISM was unequivocally bearish for equities. The Fed’s concerns about inflation are warranted. If Jerome Powell was looking to explain this week’s hawkish lean, he’s got plenty of anecdotes from the services sector to cite.

That said, the situation could reverse quickly in the event the US experiences an acute winter COVID wave that abruptly impacts high-contact businesses. And therein lies the quandary for the Fed.


Leave a Reply to jylCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

6 thoughts on “Good News Is Definitely Bad News Now

  1. For the first time in almost two years, investors face the prospects of navigating a market without the support of $ trillions in government liquidity.

    2022 is an election year so there won’t be emergency liquidity coming from Congress, and the Fed is backed into an inflation corner so no emergency liquidity from the Fed.

    I think the reflexive reaction to marginally good or bad news is misguided. “Bad” would have to be shockingly bad to have any chance of coaxing more liquidity from the well. “Good” is already baked in and at most might accelerate the taper/hikes by a couple months.

    No matter what the year brings, market denizens, we’re on our own. The dealer is no longer on our side.

    Since playing with a fair deck is not as safe as playing with a stacked deck, some chips will be – are being – pulled from the table.

    1. You make a fair point regarding “no new money” (…read my lips, eh?). But what about all the existing money, which is NOT going to be actively sucked back into the printing press? It still needs to find a home and produce something resembling a return. Front end rates are still paltry, even with a few rate hikes now priced in. And any fixed income product with a longer duration has an ongoing risk/reward problem. So, equities it is, with headlines driving sector/factor rotations from one month to the next. I’m beginning to see the wisdom in the 4,600 targets for YE 2022, i.e. an “either/or market” churn that goes nowhere at the index level.

      1. I figure that money already in the market or in cash isn’t likely to hurl itself into the abyss to halt a correction – it’s more likely to sit on the sidelines or run to cash. Well, except for the intrepid retail dip buyers. Thank goodness for them, but they wield billions not trillions.

        1. OK understood, but don’t forget other sources of “steady inflows”, e.g. buybacks, 401k contributions, public pension contributions, inherited real estate liquidated and put into securities, etc.

          Stocks had good runs before QE was a thing. Can happen again.

  2. H-Man, not sure Omicron or Delta are going to derail this economy which seems to be running on nine cylinders. Yes people are getting sick but there are no refrigeration trucks showing up at the hospitals.

    1. And because of that, fiscal aid is over. Kaput.

      Wage hikes are being offset by price hikes.

      Not that the underlying economy or earnings matters to stock prices. (Not said sarcastically.)

NEWSROOM crewneck & prints